I am posting this against (what I might mistake as) my better judgement, and only because of a promise made in passing. In the process of this I learned a couple of things:
1) I cannot be objective about this band’s music. I’ve played it all, for so long, that even the stuff that sucks is still pretty awesome because Stones.
2) I will read this in the morning and disagree with myself. In the making of this list, I altered the ordering at least three times, and then realized that getting this anywhere near precise was pretty much an impossible task from the outset. Sure, as I moved titles around, I realized that it was settling into the list you see below. And sure, I might say Let It Bleed oughta come above Beggars Banquet, or that Emotional Rescue was worse than Dirty Work… and on and on. It’s endless. What I’m saying is I’m probably dead wrong about a lot of this. Tomorrow, this list could (would) look very different! I’m so close to this stuff I can’t even see it anymore.
It’ll be really interesting to return to this a year from now and laugh at how much I would change. Note to future self: “Hi! Please be gentle!”
Well, damn the torpedoes. Here it is!
All The Rolling Stones
So Mike made an awesome post wherein he ranked all the Aerosmith albums (on request), from worst to best! This must have been a daunting task, especially since he says he hates making lists! But I loved it and suggested he do more! I listed a bunch of bands and he said he’d do one more (because he’s awesome). No KISS or Maiden, though. I thought maybe Rush… but I settled on Marillion. I think that list will be very informative (and a challenge for Mike!)
And to be a good sport, I said I’d do one too, and a challenging one at that! Yes, the Rolling Stones. It’s hard for me to say how much I like this band, but suffice it to say it’s a whole helluva lot. Am I even able to rank their albums, when I’ve listened to them for so long and am hardly objective? Unlikely.
As Mike did, I’ve left out hits collections and live albums. Studio albums (24 of them!) only.
Hooboy.
Here we go.
Let’s give ‘er…
24 Dirty Work
23 Emotional Rescue
22 Undercover
21 A Bigger Bang
20 Bridges To Babylon
19 Their Satanic Majesties Request
18 Black And Blue
17 Steel Wheels
16 Goat’s Head Soup
15 Between The Buttons
14 December’s Children (And Everybody Else’s)
13 England’s Newest Hitmakers
12 It’s Only Rock ’n Roll
11 Voodoo Lounge
10 The Rolling Stones, Now!
09 Out Of Our Heads
08 12×5
07 Some Girls
06 Tattoo You
05 Aftermath
04 Let it Bleed
03 Beggars Banquet
02 Sticky Fingers
01 Exile On Main St.
Discuss.
I love Between the Buttons and Their Satanic! Stones at their pop melodic best.
LikeLike
Both very cool records. Good call! They ranked a bit lower in my list, this time around, but that doesn’t mean I don’t like ’em! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I know what that’s like. In my case, it would be impossible to rank The Beach Boys’ albums because I love so many them. Even on their lesser albums, there’s songs that rank up there with their best…I’m assuming that’s the case with the Stones as well.
LikeLike
Oof the Beach Boys would be tough too. I haven’t heard all the records, but I’ve heard enough to know exactly what you mean!
Yeah that Stones list was a sweet agony. I stared at it a long time and finally just had to damn the torpedoes and post it. And even then I messed up! Ha and so it goes. The top four were a cinch, though. 🙂
LikeLike
I think Emotional Rescue is my favorite Stones album …. It is what it is. And I am soooo not a fan of Holidays in Eden. Blech.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Holidays won’t be on the bottom of my list, because unfortunately Mark did worse later on….
LikeLike
Don’t give me your problems!
LikeLike
I swam through the nicotine seize.
LikeLike
Actually “it is what it is” is what I would say about Holidays. It’s not anywhere near my favourite of theirs but I think it gets a bad rep.
LikeLike
I don’t remember what I rated it. 3/5? No one can take that away from you now.
LikeLike
Really? That’s not too bad… I remembered it being lower. Like a 2. Maybe a 4 from me. The only track I really didn’t like much on it was the title track.
LikeLike
Just looked back at your review. You gave it 2.75… near enough to a 3! And you made that same joke to me in the comments section hahaha
LikeLiked by 1 person
One trick pony? This guy!
Where would you rank AOS?
LikeLike
Higher up. Top 5 probably of the studio albums.
LikeLike
I like it too — more than I thought I should. I wonder if I should do two lists — Fish. And H?
And then somehow try to combine them? That might be the only way.
LikeLike
That could work. It’s a bit tricky cause I think of them like 2 different bands really. And I might be more in the mood for one than the other for a while. Right now I gravitate to the early stuff but there have been many years where I was all about the h stuff.
Right now…
1 Clutching,
2 Brave,
3 Fugazi,
4 AOS,
5 Script
would be my “off the top of my head” Top 5.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well dude I did up my first draft of the last night. 16 studio albums and a couple special mentions. Our top five has a few in common.
LikeLike
Who has two thumbs and only one joke? THIS GUY!
LikeLike
Another vote for ER! There’s another one I’ll need to revisit, I guess. I’m enjoying that people are mentioning their favourites, especially in difference to that list I posted (which I still don’t trust is correct in many places). Thanks for chiming in!
LikeLike
Also, I love that you guys are having a Marillion discussion about ranking their albums and Mike hasn’t even posted his list yet! Have at ‘er!
LikeLike
I have several projects lined up for the weekend, but a Marillion list is on top. A difficult but interesting challenge.
I love hijacking threads!
LikeLike
When Lebrain says he’s working on ‘several projects,’ we can all rest assured that the awesomeness is gonna keep on comin’. Right on.
Looks like your Marillion list is gonna generate lots of comments! Looks like I made a good choice of band!
Hijack away, man. Last thread I hijacked was over on Sarca’s excellent site. It started out about coffee and ended up hijacked into a conversation about mailing semen to Glasgow. Oh, and chicken bewbs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t know enough about the Stones to argue. Nor would I want to! Exile and Sticky Fingers up top look good to me.
You sent me all these albums a few years ago. I don’t really remember all of them, especially the early years. But I do remember liking Emotional Rescue a lot!
Marillion list is coming. I expect flak from a Scott.
LikeLike
I was about to say you don’t have any excuse, you should still have them all there! 🙂 Actually, that top four is essential.Their run from 68-72 is absolutely mind-blowing.
I’ll find a Marillion list very educational (I don’t know much about the band and trust your judgement). Haha make your own list, don’t worry about our HMO. Besides, he’s distracted – he’s been aroused by the Rolling Stones!!*
* see our 1537’s post on the Marquee..
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yup I saw his Marquee review last night! Didn’t know about that release.
I look at this and think, there are no crappy Stones albums that I know of, and I don’t remember Dirty Work at all. Now I wanna hear it again.
LikeLike
I knew about it and I want it so badly. Just waiting for the pennies to rebuild. Well, and also, I have a birthday in July and I’m usually not allowed to buy anything for myself in the run-up to events like that…
It’s true, there are no completely bad Stones records. But I am completely biased and therefore probablt can’t be trusted on that point. Dirty Work is one I oughta revisit too, at some point. I’d probably wanna change my list again, afterwards…
LikeLike
I reckon it’ll all boil down to where you put Holidays in Eden! That’s the one I’ll be watching… 😉
LikeLike
It’s on top. Obviously. 🙂
LikeLike
While I couldn’t comment too much on Mike’s Aerosmith post, I’m a lover of them Rolling Stones. I applaud you for trying to rank these – I’d find it impossible. I could make a top 10, but I don’t think I could rank them.
Anyhoo, the discuss part: I’m surprices to see Emotional Rescue and A Bigger Bang way down the list. I’d probably have A Bigger Bang (if a couple of tracks too long) up there alongside Voodoo Lounge. I’d also have Emotional Rescue in my top 10. Or sitting just outside it. Dirty Work is quite possibly my least favourite and Undercover my second least favourite. Eh, what else … oh, Their Satanic Majesties Request is also a favourite. Granted it’s not the best collection of songs they’ve released, but there’s something about it that just works.
My (current) 10: Emotional Rescue, 9 A Bigger Bang, 8 Voodoo Lounge, 7 Let It Bleed, 6 Some Girls, 5 Aftermath, 4 Tattoo You, 3 Beggars Banquet, 2 Exile On Main St, 1 Sticky Fingers.
Also, if you haven’t already you gotta get yourself over to LegoLand; 1537 done gone got something that will interest you!
LikeLike
See, I don’t disagree with your 10 either! Well, I still like Exile over Sticky, but I’ve always been weird. Anyway, as I was saying elsewhere, this was an impossible task. I could revisit this any day of the week and want to make changes. Heck, I’ve already made changes today!
I’m just a little too close to these albums, I think. I like to think of them as one big happy mix tape (thank you, iPod!) and trying to make them in order like this was just a horrible task. Like picking between kids – it just shouldn’t be done! Actually, I’ll admit this here, I was originally going to post that – that I just couldn’t do the list. Couldn’t be done. But tht seemed a cop-out so I gave ‘er the ol’ college try and… well, there it is. I disagree with it already. Bah! 🙂
I saw 1537’s post, and am on my way to comment…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I tip my hat to you for giving it a shot, sir.
Hurrah! for the Rolling Stones!
LikeLike
Ha thanks! Although now I’m thinking I shouldn’t have. Now that it exists and is out there, I feel weird about it. I see all sorts of errors! Gah!
Oh yes I’ve loved me some Stones for a loooong time. So much a part of my life I can’t even imagine music without them.
LikeLike
Ach, no – there’s no harm in having a list that came with a caveat of ‘this will change’. It’s a good effort … and a good reference for folk who might be looking at further listening.
LikeLike
Well thanks, but I still wonder… I guess it’s tough because until doing this it never crossed my mind to rank them like that! I just take them all in one big happy pile. But yeah, if it helps somebody choose a new (to them) album to try, great. So long as they remember I still like the lowest ranked ones too, so it’s all relative. 🙂
LikeLike
Aw man, as much as I try with some of those albums I just can’t like them. Especially the ‘Jagger transition’ stuff. When he’s becoming a ‘product’. Horrible stuff … his posturing and the slickness jars a bit with the music. That’s my opinion right enough. That being said, Stones!
LikeLike
At times like those, I always say forget Mick and just watch/listen to Keef. He reminds you why they’re there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha. Can’t disagree with that I guess!
LikeLike
Wowzers…Some Girls @ 20! But like HMO Sez thyas what these lists are for….A Bigger Bang J recommended to me and I took the plunge and I quite like it but I have only spun it a few times …but yeah these are kinda cool these lists……
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, Some Girls was an error (see above comments). A Bigger Bang is good too. Like I said to HMO, even the low-ranked records are ones I still like.
You gonna try a list, Deke? Say… All The Sebastian Bach (Whom Deke Is Stalking)?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you picked that one up and fairly enjoyed it, Deke. Hopefully it continues to grow on you with each spin!
LikeLike
Yeah dude thanks for the heads up on this one!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Only a toe-dipper with the Stones so I can’t really say yay or nay to this. I’m pretty surprised at Some Girls being so low though, thought that was supposed to be one of their better ones?… I’m intrigued as to why you don’t feel that way about it. That’s the fun of these kind of lists though!
LikeLike
Some Girls was an error (Boppinsblog caught it first!) so I’ll correct that.
The other thing about this list is that even the albums I ranked very low, I still like them. It’s like picking between children for me. I hope I never do this again! 🙂
LikeLike
Also Before They Make Me Run is Keef’s best song in my humble opinion.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oof I don’t think I could pick a favourite of his… BTMMR is a great tune, I can’t argue that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love bands that have so much talent that they have more than one vocalist. Especially when the other singer sounds so unique and different. Kiss, Triumph, Fleetwood Mac, The Eagles, The Band, The Beatles, The Cars, ZZ Top, Cream, CSNY, Floyd, etc. etc. Although perhaps no other band has as unique a singer as Keef, that sounds so much different than Mick. He doesn’t have that classic vocal sound, and he looks like he should have been dead 40 years ago, but he is friggin’ awesome.
LikeLike
Oh yes absolutely. And just as often, there are bands with two singers where one of the singers most certainly shouldn’t be singing at all!
Another band with singers who sound very different (but it all works and we wouldn’t have it any other way) is Blue Rodeo. I love those guys too.
“He doesn’t have that classic vocal sound, and he looks like he should have been dead 40 years ago, but he is friggin’ awesome.” You said it all there, my friend!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I thought about including Blue Rodeo. I was never a big fan, as I was sure at least one of them would start crying during a song. But, my tastes have been expanding so I might start getting into them. perhaps I will start with one of my numerous copies of Live In Stratford. 😉
LikeLike
Numerous copies?
Now, I have a question for you: are they all of the same show (the January 14th is most common), or do you have both nights? Because I NEED the January 13 show and I will pay cash monies (without hesitation) for a copy!
LikeLike
Sorry. I put the winky face there because I was joking. I have never seen it out in my travels, and I know you and Mike have it on the Grail list. I would not hesitate to let you guys have it if I ever find it.
LikeLike
Aw crap. Well OK, thanks for keeping an eye peeled! So if you find one, do Mike and I gotta arm wrestle for it? He’d probably whup me…
LikeLike
Oh man! Can you imagine??? We’d have to film it. The first ever Battle for Blue Rodeo. Fuck I wish we could do that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was windering that as well. I was thinking of a wredting ring and placing it in the middle. Maybe an eating contest. A drinking contest. Or maybe a music knowledge contest. HMMMM.
LikeLike
Well, after all these years I’m fairly aware of my own weaknesses and strengths, so I would say the drinking contest should come first. After that, I’d wager my chance would improve in an arm wrestle or music knowledge situation but only because it might slightly lessen Mike’s strengths in those areas!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve got it. A Lebrain vs. Keeps Me Alive challenge somilar to Kenny vs. Spenny. Maybe a fart smelling contest.
Or. A cjallenge when you go to Taranna
You each get a set amount of cash and bring back the best goodies. The one that gets the best haul my opinion wins. This seems like a good challenge even just for bragging rights.
LikeLike
I don’t know Kenny v. Spenny but I’ve already smelled Mike’s farts in my lovely wife’s car.
I like the Taranna challenge. Are there parameters? Or just Whatever We Buy gets judged?
LikeLike
If there is anything you buy for someone else it is exempt. if you buy a grail list item it is exempt. Anything you buy for yourself is included.
Beyond that you guys can make up whatever rules you want before hand. I don’t want to limit your fun trip. You can change the $ limit parameter too. It could be on a ratio of how much spent/value/cool quotient/rarity etc. You could also make the voting up to the blogging community at the end. Up to you guys.
LikeLike
Or could be exactly as you say, but you as the official judge and rule decider.
LikeLike
You guys let me know. I am up for it either way.
LikeLike
I’m in. It’ll be in the fall, though, and I have a very good memory but it’s short. When we start talking about going, remind us! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
An interesting idea! I’d have to work pretty hard to keep up with Mike – he tends to buy the Rawk and a lot of the Readers of the blog are into the Rawk. If I start adding in Ani DiFrancos and other stuff not in the wheelhouse, I might lose votes! Haha 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Enthusiasm will earn extra points, and I know you have that. As well, excessive use of the word givver. Especially if you use it in a sentence such as the one I used to say in High School.
“Let’s givver ’til the governor gives ‘er.”
If you like Ani Defranco, and other stuff I don’t know about, I will take that into account. I also want a chance to research the music afterwards. I won’t automatically award more points for stuff I like. If you or Mike convert me to something new that might be worth even more.
LikeLike
I’m digging it. What it’s boiling down to, then, is just go do what we usually do anyway! 🙂
LikeLike
Yes. I will for warn you if you buy anything Trooper, James Blunt, Nickelback, Creed, Drops of Jupiter, No Rain, Harlem Shake, What the Fox Say, Gangnam Style, Crazy Frog, Alvin and the Chipmunks I don’t like your odds.
LikeLike
Well I’m fairly certain none of those things will be on the list, so I’m already winning!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did he ever try the ” I think there is a skunk” trick?
Reminds me of a lyric in If a tree Falls. “Grain Eaters. Methane Dispensers.”
LikeLike
If he tried that, he’d find out If I Had A Rocket Launcher or not…
LikeLiked by 1 person
You could always put ghost pepper in his drink to give him Cockburn.
LikeLike
Haha ouch. In hoping it’d all pass, he’d be Waiting For A Miracle.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha ouch. In hoping it’d all pass, he’d be Waiting For A Miracle.
LikeLike
It would be a while until he could show his great big love for fear of becoming lovers in a dangerous time.
LikeLike
aaaaaaaaand I’m out! Hahahahahaaaaaa!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like it when Keef sings! The Worst is another shaky classic!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I had a truck with a cassette deck that had Some Girls stuck in it. I really liked that album before that, But loved it after. There is not one filler song on that album. I would put it ahead of all of the 60’s era, all of the 80-present, and ahead of most of the 70’s albums. For me easily top 5, maybe top 3. I don’t think I have ever seen it ranked so poorly. Why do you hate it so? Is it just my imagination, or do you not think it is very respectable?
LikeLike
You’re absolutely right. I looked at that list so long it made sense to me, and I hit Post and it should not be there. I see where the error is, too. I’ll fix it. Nice catch, thanks!
Also, I had a Civic that had a mixed tape of Me First And The Gimme Gimmes stuck in the tape deck. Good thing I love those guys! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, I’ll tell you no Lies, this oversight left this Beast Of Burden quite Shattered. But I appreciate When the Whip Comes Down and points out my errors (made by looking at the list with Far Away Eyes)!
Oh man, I could do this stuff all day!
I also need to report that when I went to correct Some Girls’ position (which honestly was an error), I was so tempted to change more. And then, well, that one should rank higher and that one lower and… I had to get out of it. I’d be here changing the list’s order all frickin’ day!
LikeLiked by 1 person